College or Pro: MLB The Show 25 Career Path Decision

MLB The Show 25 has arrived, bringing with it a fresh and immersive Road to the Show experience. This beloved career mode lets you step into the cleats of a rising baseball star, chasing the dream of making it to the Major Leagues. But right from the start, you’re faced with a pivotal decision: should you go to college or go pro in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show?

This year’s iteration shakes things up by placing you in the role of a high school standout on the cusp of a life-changing choice. Scouts from top colleges and professional teams are watching your every move as your high school squad pushes for a state championship. Regardless of the outcome on the field, your performance—combined with your showing at the MLB Combine—will shape your future. Strong stats and a solid Combine can boost your draft stock and expand your list of college suitors.

After the Combine, you’ll formally commit to a college or enter the MLB Draft. Even if you plan to go pro, you’ll still receive a draft pick. The game clearly outlines your path based on your decision. Here’s a breakdown of the options presented:

If I Go Pro

• Receive a signing bonus of 5 Tokens
• Lower chance of being fast-tracked to the Major Leagues
• Begin your professional career at just 18 years old

If I Go To College

• Gain all benefits from LSU’s official offer (or your chosen school)
• Compete to become the #1 overall pick in a future MLB Draft
• Start your pro career at 21, after completing your college journey

Ultimately, the decision comes down to how you want to experience the Road to the Show. If you’ve spent past seasons grinding through the minors, going the college route offers a refreshing change. Entering the draft as the top pick brings prestige and a more polished skill set, making your Major League debut feel even more rewarding. Plus, the game fast-forwards through your college years, dropping you right into your third year during a championship run—so you get the full college experience without the long wait.

The Escapist chose the college path, drawn by the allure of becoming the #1 overall pick and the unique narrative depth it adds. It’s a balanced choice that delivers development, excitement, and a quicker transition to the pros than you might expect.

So, should you go to college or go pro in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show? Both paths offer distinct advantages and storytelling opportunities. Whether you want to start young and climb from the bottom or build your legacy through college and aim for the top spot, your journey is yours to shape.

For more tips, check out the best pitching settings for MLB The Show 25.

MLB The Show 25 is now available in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.